Review: #21351 The Nightmare Before Christmas (LEGO Ideas)
Can the magic of Tim Burton’s 1993 classic film be captured using LEGO Bricks? Let’s find out, and explore the many details hidden within this set!
What’s this? What’s this? There’s LEGO everywhere. What’s this? A world of blocks beyond compare!
Two years on from submission to the LEGO IDEAS platform we see #21351 The Nightmare Before Christmas hit the shelves. Packed with iconic figures, cool shapes and colors and memorable scenes from the iconic movie this set seems to have it all. Lets find out how this set compares to its original submission and what is in store for you should you pick up this set.
The Nightmare Before Christmas
Hitting cinemas on October 13th, 1993, Tim Burton’s The Nightmare Before Christmas is a stop-motion claymation musical fantasy film directed by Henry Selick and produced by Tim Burton. The story follows Jack Skellington, the Pumpkin King of Halloween Town, who discovers Christmas Town and becomes obsessed with bringing Christmas to his spooky world, leading to a series of unintended consequences. Upon release the movie received mixed reviews, with questions being raised over whether to classify it as a Halloween or Christmas film. It has since become a beloved cult classic, praised for its unique visual style, memorable characters, and the iconic soundtrack by Danny Elfman. The movie’s blend of dark themes with whimsical storytelling has made it a holiday staple for both Halloween and Christmas.
About the set
#21351 The Nightmare Before Christmas hits the shelves for the general public on the 6th of September 2024, with LEGO Insiders having early access starting the 3rd of September 2024. The set includes 2193 pieces and is being released at a retail price of $199.99 (€199.99/£169.99) giving it a price per part of $0.091 (€0.091.99/£0.078). Included in this set are 8 iconic minifigures from Tim Burton’s iconic film and a newly molded dog. While the set has a large piece count it is a rather dense set with regards to builds, sized at height of 13″ (32cm), a width of 21″ (51cm) and a depth of 11″ (27cm) once fully assembled. Dense however does not mean lacking of detail as we will see as we build this set further. This set was timed perfectly to be released before Halloween, allowing fans to purchase, build and display the set in time for the holiday.
- LEGO Parts Count: 2193
- LEGO Parts Weight: 1514 grams
- Price per part: $199.99 / 2193 parts = $0.091 per part
- Price per gram: $199.99 / g = $0.132 per gram
LEGO Ideas submission
Coming through the LEGO IDEAS program, #21351 The Nightmare Before Christmas is the 59th set to be revealed as part of the LEGO IDEAS line. LEGO fan designer Simon Scott (who goes by the LEGO Ideas name Tvrulesmylife) first built this set to be displayed at various LEGO shows in the UK, with positive feedback encouraging him to submit it to the LEGO IDEAS program. First submitted on July 29th 2022, the popularity of the designs skyrocketed, hitting the 10,000 supporters required on September 4th 2022, less than two months from submission. It did not take long for this set to be approved by LEGO, becoming a real set less than two years after approval. While the LEGO often makes a lot of changes to IDEAS submissions, the LEGO designers of this set did a great job ensuring that the essence of the original submission was kept, with the only change in minifigures being the replacement of Dr. Finkelstein with the Mayor of Halloween Town.
Packaging and stickers
With an adult target audience and given its 18+ rating, the designers have gone with the dark box art design. While normally this is used to represent the iconic adult wave of sets it has a second allure here to highlight the Halloween themed set. Both the front and the back cover do a great job at illustrating the contents, almost giving away too many of included details included. What is not clear by the box was whether the full moon is an included piece or whether it was part of the box’s design. Fortunately it was nost just a graphic, adding details to the build. The confusion though shows that LEGO sometimes is overly reliant on box art to add details in the background.
The box captures some of the magic of old LEGO sets from the 80s and 90s with a top raising lid. By cutting four pieces of tape on the side the top slides off and can be placed back on to preserve the box with minimal damage. This is the second time I have seen LEGO opt for this box style and it is a welcome change, making it easy to store and and provides a space to place parts in during the build. Although introduced a few years ago this is only the third time I have seen LEGO include paper bags instead of plastic bags to house the pieces. I hope to see more sets shift to this as we move to a more environmentally sustainable way to store pieces. While the outer bags were made of paper, some of the inner bags were still made of plastic though which almost defeats the purpose of paper bags.
Although this is a large set the inclusion of three instruction manuals was a surprise. As LEGO moves more in the direction of collaborative building experiences, we see how this influenced the builds, with each structure being able to be built independently and connected at the end. With this intentional choice in design the designers break up each structure into its own build and instruction manual. While this review will follow each build in the order of instructions I actually built it out of order, with the last build being my first to test whether this has any impact on building experience.
While the set does have a lot of details it was a bit of a let down to see that most of the printed details came in the form of stickers. While understandable, this omission feels a little cheap, especially as some of the stickers could have been printed tiles that could be reused in other sets. This did not worsen my build experience but given its high price point could have heightened the experience if included. While stickers have complaints, what was welcome was the large full moon included in this set. I nearly did not notice this was part of the set, nearly tossing it as it was wedged the instructions manual box. This detail is a great addition to the scene and makes The Spiral Hill the iconic scene it is. LEGO could have chosen to leave it out but I am glad they did not.
Build Process
#21351 The Nightmare Before Christmas is split into three builds that can be built in parallel, each depicting an iconic scene from the films. After building each of the three builds they can be combined to create one larger build, allowing you to display them together or separately. To help get into the spirit of the movies I both watched the films and listened to the soundtrack during the duration of my build and I have included a link to the songs that are played during each of the scenes in the set for you to enjoy.
Town hall
Jack Skellington’s Houseouse
The Spiral Hill
Minifigures
All the minifigures in this set with the exception of the Mayor were included in the original LEGO Ideas submission, with the Mayor replacing Dr. Finkelstein. Wile it would be nice to have both I feel the mayor is a cooler character. Due to the nature of this being a unique set, each version of the minifigure in this set is currently exclusive, with a variant of Jack, Sally and Sandy Claws (Santa) being available in other forms. Included in this set are the stars, Jack, Sally and Zero, each immediately recognizable. Sandy Claws (Santa) although unique is probably the most generic of the minifigures included, being someone who could have been included in other holiday sets. This generic nature doesn’t mean it is not a great figure though, with some great unique printing including candy corns printing on his torso only visible if you remove his beard, a fun Easter Egg. Lock, Shock and Barrel are the next three included. These characters are rather plain but that is not LEGO’s fault as their attire in the movies are plain as well. The final minifigure, if you can even call this a minifigure is the brick built Mayor. This eclectic bunch of characters capture the magic of the films but I feel we are missing one character that would elevate this set further. This being Oogie Boogie. I wish we had received a big fig or even minifigure of this iconic character, something we may never see given I do not expect them to release another The Nightmare Before Christmas set in the future.
Both Jack and Sally make their second appearance in LEGO form in this set, first being released in 2019 as part of the Collectible Minifigures Disney Series 2. Both of them have gotten a upgrade, with Jack utilizing the longer legs to help accentuate his skeletal features. The details and printing of the figures are exquisite, making them the stars of the included minifigures. Arm, leg and torso printing help showcase these details. My favorite detail included in these characters is the bat bowtie that Jack wears, I hope these make their way to pick-a-brick so I can pick up some more. We cannot talk details without talking about Zero. When it comes to recognizability and detail I don’t think I have seen a better animal. It is so detailed that it almost doesn’t even feel like LEGO, moving more into the realm of action figure details. While I am sure this will be a topic of discussion for some in the community I love the details included in Zero and look forward to seeing more pop culture references with this level of detail.
While Lock, Shock and Barrel have rather plain outfits they capture the expressions of the characters in the films well. Of the three characters only Barrel has a printed torso, with Lock and Shock having plain unprinted torsos. I wish that these characters had the masks they wore in the films as an accessory, but given that these would be new molds I understand why they were not used. In the films the characters had irregular shaped heads, something that could not be accomplished in LEGO form, but to make up for this we are met with detailed prints that accurately capture the characters’ facial features. A fun observation, Barrel’s head and hair combination looks eerily similar to that of the Joker from Batman. While not a minifigure I love that this set includes the Barrel Bathtub, the mount that these characters ride in and use to transport Sandy Claws upon capturing him. The brick built tub is large enough to fit all three characters, utilizing skeleton legs to add posability.
The most unique character is te Mayor. To capture his size and shape the character is built using various bricks, with most of the printed parts being used to capture his details. Everything from his arms to legs and even top hat are built with bricks and is a ton of fun to put together. While LEGO often opts to only use dual molded facial expressions if the alternate expressions is hidden by hair or a head in this set it makes sense to have both exposed, as they are in the films. The cone used for his head can be rotated to show both expressions. I am glad that this minifigure was included, especially given that the set includes a town hall structure, if we had to chose I prefer this to the original Dr. Finkelstein minifigure.
While the absence is not a detractor, the inclusion could do a lot to make this set even better. This set does not include a outfit recolor of Christmas Jack Skellington. Due to Jack’s long appendages you cannot easily swap out Sandy Claws’ torso and legs without it looking odd. While this detail would only have added a few parts I think it would have made the set greater and capture more of the films’ narrative. At the very least I feel they should have included an extra Santa hat. While not perfect even just the addition of the Santa hat does a lot to capture the Christmas magic of this character stuck in a holiday identity crisis.
Value
While it is easy to complain about prices this set is a mixed bag when it comes to value, with some of this being attributed to Disney Tax. The price-per-part is below the 10c gold standard, but as we have explored this can be manipulated easily. When we look at price-per-gram we have the second worst value at $0.132 per gram, only being beaten by a Star Wars set that suffers from the same Disney tax. Despite this, see some fun building experiences and have 8 great minifigures including a new mold for Zero the ghost dog. While not attributed to value, where this set also suffers from being a large set at a high price tag. $199.99 is a steep price for many making this set inaccessible for those who want a taste of Disney without needing to buy the whole set. LEGO’s shift to the adult market has seen this occur time and time again, with the number of sets in excess of $100 growing. This does result in trade-offs, while less accessible it does mean that we get better, bigger and more detailed builds, as I cannot imagine how the same details could be caught in a set of half the price. I do wish that we could see something like The Spiral Hill released as a $70 set with 3 minifigures, instead of a set triple its price, but I digress.
When you compare the set to others recently released you can see how this compares, seeing some numbers almost being twice as expensive as some of the unlicensed sets. The experience and spacious nature of the set, while not quantifable also adds to the appeal and value. To compare this set and its metrics to other sets you can refer to the table below. Value is subjective but being data driven is a good way to compare.
LEGO Set | Price | Part Count | Price-per-part | Weight | Price-per-gram |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
#31203 World Map | $249.99 | 11,695 pieces | $0.021 per-piece | 4020 grams | $0.062 per-gram |
#21056 Taj Mahal | $119.99 | 2022 pieces | $0.059 per-piece | 1811 grams | $0.066 per-gram |
#21058 Great Pyramid of Giza | $129.99 | 1476 pieces | $0.088 per-piece | 1832 grams | $0.071 per-gram |
#10278 Police Station | $199.99 | 2923 pieces | $0.068 per-piece | 2602 grams | $0.077 per-gram |
#71799 Ninjago City Markets | $369.99 | 6163 pieces | $0.06 per piece | 4770 grams | $0.078 per-gram |
#71741 Ninjago City Gardens | $299.99 | 5685 pieces | $0.052 per piece | 3719 grams | $0.081 per-gram |
#71043 Hogwarts Castle | $399.99 | 6020 pieces | $0.066 per-piece | 4899 grams | $0.082 per-gram |
#10292 Friends – The Apartments | $149.99 | 2048 pieces | $0.073 per-piece | 1778 grams | $0.084 per-gram |
#10297 Boutique Hotel | $199.99 | 3066 pieces | $0.065 per-piece | 2380 grams | $0.084 per-gram |
#21343 Viking Village | $129.99 | 2103 pieces | $0.062 per piece | 1448 grams | $0.09 per-gram |
#42639 Andrea’s Modern Mansion | $199.99 | 2275 pieces | $0.088 per piece | 2116 grams | $0.095 per-gram |
#10312 Jazz Club | $229.99 | 2899 pieces | $0.079 per-piece | 2392 grams | $0.096 per-gram |
#10270 Bookshop | $199.99 | 2504 pieces | $0.080 per-piece | 2085 grams | $0.096 per-gram |
#10282 Adidas Originals Superstar | $79.99 | 731 pieces | $0.109 per-piece | 735 grams | $0.109 per-gram |
#10316 Rivendell | $499.99 | 6167 pieces | $0.081 per piece | 4375 grams | $0.114 per-gram |
#10305 Lion Knights’ Castle | $399.99 | 4514 pieces | $0.089 per piece | 3265 grams | $0.122 per-gram |
#10303 Loop Coaster | $399.99 | 3756 pieces | $0.106 per-piece | 3189 grams | $0.125 per-gram |
#21351 The Nightmare Before Christmas (this set) | $199.99 | 2193 pieces | $0.091 per piece | 1514 grams | $0.132 per-gram |
#75290 Mos Eisley Cantina | $399.99 | 3187 pieces | $0.126 per piece | 2521 grams | $0.158 per-gram |
Conclusion
#21351 The Nightmare Before Christmas is a fun set thanks to a great selection of minifigures, fun building techniques, and fun details. The LEGO designers did a great job at not only capturing the details of the films but also ensured that the set did not steer too far away from the original submitted IDEAS design. Having built this set while watching the movies and listening to the soundtrack accentuated the build experience for me and is something I recommend those who pick up this set try. I cannot factor that enjoyment into a review that looks just at the set though.
The audience for this set is rather niche, and I worry that only real die hard fans of the films will pick up this set because of the high price tag. At a $199.99 price, #21351 The Nightmare Before Christmas is not an impulse buy and is easily passable for the majority of LEGO fans. All things considered I give this set a respectible 3/5 Stars (Good), with the desirability rising for a subset of fans. Were this set priced ~10% less and included a Oogie Boogie minifigure that would be enough to bump this up, but when comparing to other sets at a higher rating this falls just short of the mark, with it teetering just on the fence.
I think that they are missing out by not having Oogie Boogie and his casino not included with this set. I would rather have it than the mayor and town hall. And maybe have the mayor in his car? But Oogie Boogie would be the reason for this Lego fan & fan of the movie to buy the set.